Just to add some context to my evaluations, here's the order I judged the entries in: Sonic Chaos Quest Ultimate Sonic 1: Colors Edition (SHC2017 Demo) Sonic Double Dash Sonic & Ashuro SADX Lantern Engine Achi (AKA another trend in gaming that is slightly annoying and ultimately pointless) Sonic 1 - Comet Edition v2.1 Mr. Cat's 16 day challenge! A Rushed Sonic Hack Sonic 1 Dragon Edition Sonic 3 Chaos Adventure Sonic Legacy Classic Pantufa the Cat DX Sonic 2: Zen Island A generic Sonic 1 ROMhack Dr Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine - DX Edition Heroes Mod Loader & Tweakbox (Tech Demo) Sonic Redux (Character Demo) Tails Adventure X-L Metal Sonic Rebooted Sonic Egg Factory ReMastered Sonic 1 Back to South Island (SHC17 Demo) Sonic Halloween I used a random number generator to select which hack to judge next. The idea is that, in my experience, a judge will get more tired and harder to impress as they play more entries, so I may be too easy on early entries (probably Sonic Chaos Quest Ultimate), and too harsh on later ones (especially Metal Sonic Rebooted). Same goes for evaluation length: Chaos Quest got a pretty massive one, but they got shorter as I went through the rest of the entries. Playing in a random order meant I at least wasn't putting certain hacks at a disadvantage because of where they lied in alphabetical order. Hopefully this list will put a few things into perspective, and explain any inconsistencies.